Big Ol’ Pumpkin Roll Baking SUCCESS!

I had to. I couldn’t leave it at ugly (here’s the story of the ugly pumpkin roll). I had to try again to make a beautiful (read: presentable-looking) pumpkin roll… And I did it! LOOK AT THAT SWIRL!

photo 4

You know how?? By following the recipe. People, recipes work. Just do yourself a favor and follow them. I used Libby’s Pumpkin Roll, the classic, and it was really not too tough. Just be seriously careful when you’re rolling it in the towel. Last time since we had more of a bread than cake, it fell apart. But this time, the spongy cake rolled beautifully and left us with a pumpkin roll worthy of a Friendsgiving feast!


So now it’s all wrapped up, looking like a burrito, and ready for the party!! And I’m feeling pretty proud that I turned my baking fail into a baking success!! 🙂

Big Ol’ Pumpkin Roll Baking Fail

I would love to tell you that I successfully made a beautiful pumpkin roll with my friend Chelsea last night. I would love to tell you that it looked just like this:

Screen Shot 2014-11-12 at 9.05.53 PM

But, alas, I believe in honesty.

And Chelsea & I made the world’s ugliest pumpkin roll. Haha! It was really so funny and even more importantly so. much. fun.

I needed a baking night with a gal pal, and the hubbies enjoyed it too! They watched BuzzFeed videos on the couch as we made a mess in the kitchen. And I mean a mess. I should’ve taken a photo of THAT. We baked and baked and thought we were making the world’s prettiest pumpkin roll (it did come out of the oven beautifully), but then when we rolled it, the thing TOTALLY fell apart.

Here’s our ugly pumpkin roll:


Hahahaha! I think it’s SO funny! That poor little thing. We oooo-ed and ahhh-ed, and then OHHH NOOO-ed and he didn’t even see it coming. Haha!

He was no Apple Crisp or Pumpkin Oreo Cheesecake… That’s for sure. (Those were success stories.)

In little rolly’s defense though, he is DELICIOUS. Soft pumpkin bread with maple cream cheese icing on the inside. There’s really not a thing in the world wrong with him except for that outer appearance.

But I still might try again tomorrow night to see if I can make a prettier product… I am supposed to take it to Friendsgiving this weekend, after all…

{Update: I tried again and there’s a success story too!!}